Lives saved.

A federal appeals court handed a significant legal win to the Trump administration by ruling that many illegal immigrants detained by ICE can be held without bond hearings during removal proceedings.

Illegal immigrants nabbed by ICE do not have to face bond hearings, a step that has become a potential legal impediment to President Donald Trump’s mass deportation agenda, a second federal court found Wednesday.

In a 2–1 decision, the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals overturned a lower court ruling in Minnesota, aligning with a similar decision from the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals. The case centered on a Mexican national detained in Minneapolis who had been granted a chance to challenge his detention.

The appellate court found that individuals in his situation can legally be detained without bond, reinforcing the administration’s broader deportation efforts. Attorney General Pam Bondi called the ruling a “massive victory” for law enforcement and immigration policy.

Trump scores ‘massive court victory’ with appellate ruling on ICE detention

The Eighth Circuit reversed a Minnesota district court ruling in a 2-1 decision, aligning with a similar Fifth Circuit ruling last month

By Charles Creitz, Fox News, March 25, 2026:

Illegal immigrants nabbed by ICE do not have to face bond hearings, a step that has become a potential legal impediment to President Donald Trump’s mass deportation agenda, a second federal court found Wednesday.

The case involved Mexican national Joaquin Herrera Avila, who was captured in Minneapolis in August and failed to produce legal credentials authorizing his admission to the U.S. He was detained without bond and faced removal proceedings.

“Massive court victory against activist judges and for President Trump’s law and order agenda,” Attorney General Pam Bondi said after the St. Louis-based Eighth Circuit reversed a lower court’s ruling and deemed many captured illegal immigrants ineligible for such chances to be released.

A district court in Minnesota granted Avila’s petition for habeas corpus, or to challenge the legality of his detention, which the Trump administration challenged.

“We reverse and remand [that ruling] for proceedings consistent with this opinion,” the Eighth Circuit ruled Wednesday in a split decision, with George W. Bush-appointed Judge Bobby Shepherd of Arkansas writing for the majority.

Shepherd wrote that the district court relied on federal law allowing detention without bond for “an alien who is an applicant for admission [or] seeking admission…” while considering Avila to be no longer seeking formal admission because he had resided and worked in the U.S. for many years. But, Avila did not seek further residency status such as naturalization or asylum, according to the court, which ruled that aspect proved he was not “seeking admission” in a legal sense.

“The Eighth Circuit has held that illegal aliens can be detained without bond — following a similar ruling from the Fifth Circuit last month. The law is very clear, but Democrats and activist judges haven’t wanted to enforce it. This administration will,” Bondi said.

“Imagine how many illegal alien crimes could have been averted if the left had simply followed the law?”

BORDER PATROL CHIEF BOVINO SAYS CHICAGO EFFORTS ‘VINDICATED’ AFTER COURT REVERSES ORDER RESTRICTING OPERATIONS

Federal agents arrest a protester outside an Immigration and Customs Enforcement facility in Minneapolis
Federal agents arrest a protester outside an Immigration and Customs Enforcement facility in Minneapolis on Jan. 9. (Mostafa Bassim/Anadolu)

placeholder
The Eighth Circuit’s ruling concurs with a related ruling from the New Orleans-based Fifth Circuit, which found that noncitizens can be held without bond, according to Bloomberg Law.

“If Congress wanted to make clear that ‘seeking admission’ was an independent requirement in the statute, it could have easily done so,” the court added.

Right-wing commentator Gunther Eagleman tweeted that the decision was indeed a win against “activist judges.”

“The Eighth Circuit just overturned an activist judge and upheld ICE’s mass detention policy in a 2-1 ruling,” he said, as a Trump appointee joined Shepherd in concurrence and another dissented.

“Key decision: Illegal aliens already inside the U.S. can be detained without bond during removal proceedings. This is a massive victory for the deportation mission. Leftist judges can no longer force DHS to simply release invaders into our communities to commit more crimes. Huge L for open borders,” Eagleman said.

In his dissent, Trump-appointed Judge Ralph R. Erickson of Minnesota said that with the exception of a single DUI conviction, Avila had lived as a law-abiding resident for just under 20 years.

Continued…..